Lectionary Guide: Holy Week 2024

March 29 | Good Friday | Year B

Isaiah 52:13–53:12

Psalm 31:9-16 | Philippians 2:5-11 | Mark 11:1-11

Summary of the Text

Eunice (“Junior”) McGarrahan

Ancient Lens

Israel’s State of Mind

The Book of Isaiah is a remarkable accounting of the history of the relationship people of Israel with God. By the time the people of God were hearing the Word of the Lord from the Book of Isaiah, the Kingdom of David was gone and there were doubts as to whether God would fulfill the promise of a glorious kingdom that would last forever. How can anyone believe a promise of glory when one is in exile, suffering humiliation and dishonor? Who is to blame for this downfall? Where is hope, if any, to be found? Isaiah is quite clear about this.

The Fault Lines of Captivity

As the people of God heard the prophet’s words, there was no place to hide. From the very beginning of Isaiah, they are told that they are corrupt, rebellious, even “laden with iniquity!” (Isaiah 1:4, ESV). Judgment is woven throughout the entire book – sometimes as warnings not to do it again. As God’s people yearned for something better, for perhaps an acknowledgment that they had not been abandoned forever, Isaiah speaks of good news that comes from a holy but redemptive God. The fault is ours. As the people learn to confess their sin and culpability, there comes from the Lord a thundering, “Yes, but…!”

 

The Horizon of Hope

Judgment is not the last word the people hear. There is a promise of healing, salvation, and restoration. But it does not come as a message of what God wants from us. It is a message that someone will come to be what God wants for us. And what God will do is send a suffering Servant who will bear the guilt, weight, and punishment of the people’s sin and who will be offered as a sacrifice to atone for and remedy the broken condition of humanity. The power of the Lord will be revealed in suffering, but the suffering is not the end of the story. Although the fault is ours, hope is from God and God alone. Because of the willing submission of the Servant, “Out of the anguish of his soul he shall see and be satisfied; by his knowledge shall the righteous one, my servant, make many to be accounted righteous, and he shall bear their iniquities. Therefore I will divide him a portion with the many, and he shall divide the spoil with the strong” (Is 53:11-12, ESV).

Jesus Lens

Who is the Suffering Servant?

Much has been written about the identity of the suffering Servant. Some believe that it might have been an unknown person who lived out this description. Some think it may have been Isaiah himself. And others think it may have been the people of Israel themselves. But as John Oswalt points out in both of his commentaries, none of those examples fit the redemptive pattern of Jesus. Thus, whether this is a prophecy or a promise, the description fits Jesus to a “T.”

 

Hope Fulfilled

The early disciples, as well as the first converts, were steeped in the Old Testament scriptures and promises. They longed for a salvation that would come in the person of the Messiah. It is worth noting that when Jesus announced His ministry in the synagogue in Nazareth, he quoted from Isaiah and then said that the promises of that book had been fulfilled in Him. The reaction of the people was just like the description Isaiah wrote about the Suffering Servant. The Servant is right in front of people, and he was unrecognized.

But after the resurrection, the connection between Jesus and the promise of Isaiah was instant and electric! The gospel writers saw the connection. The apostles saw the connection. One hates to be frivolous during Holy Week, but there seem to have been many disciples slapping their foreheads in delayed recognition.

This Isaiah passage describes who Jesus is and what He does. Many have called the Book of Isaiah the Gospel of Isaiah because of its clear and deep understanding of our human need and the salvation that Jesus alone provides. Only Jesus can do it and He has done it. One of the first missionary encounters recorded (Acts 8:26-40) turns on Isaiah 53, as Philip explains to the Ethiopians how the text he is reading is fulfilled in Jesus.

Modern Lens

Our condition

As much as technology tells us that we are always progressing to higher levels of human life, we know that’s not true. We see suffering around us: wars are breaking out globally, political divisions make civic life almost impossible, cities that were once beautiful and a vibrant have descended into a darkness of crime and hopelessness. But the despair pervades more than our national and community settings. Our personal relationships break down, our families split apart, and purpose seems to be missing from our work. And there is no political, economic, or social solution to all of these breakdowns. We cry out with the apostle Paul, “Who will deliver me from this body of death?” (Romans 7:24, ESV)

It is in this sad condition that Jesus comes to us. He is God with us. He suffers with us – He knows what we are going through. This is good to know when we have no words to describe our situation in our prayers. But Jesus also suffers for us. He does for us what we cannot do for ourselves.  And He rescues us “from the human condition, the death we see all around us, and that which we find inside ourselves. In this story of the Servant’s death and resurrection, we discover the love of God that leads to true life.” (Mackie) And this true life includes living as Jesus, the suffering Servant, lived.

It’s the story of God’s defeat of evil so that you and I can be rescued from the human condition, the death we see all around us, and that which we find inside ourselves. In this story of the servant’s death and resurrection, we discover the love of God that leads to true life.

As good as our rescue from sin and death is, we, as followers of Jesus, are called to live his life. Martin Luther said that because of the death and resurrection of Jesus, we can and must go into our neighborhoods as “little Christs.” Philippians 2: 5-11 is poetically brilliant at making the connection between the life of Jesus and our lives. As we preach, it is tempting to jump to what we do rather quickly, but with Suffering Servant description in Isaiah, we must reflect deeply on the sufferings of Jesus before we move on to what a life of suffering may look like for the follower of Jesus. It is important to not let either reflection slip into describing martyrdom.

References

Tim Mackie, “Isaiah and the Suffering Servant,” The Bible Project, accessed 12/11/2023.

Sermon resources

Key Quotes

John Calvin comments on the Suffering Servant passages: “The loftiness of the mystery is a reason why it scarcely obtains credit in the world. It is reckoned to be folly, because it exceeds all human capacities.” Ligonier Ministries adds: “Achieving exaltation through suffering is a strange thing indeed. If is foolishness in our way of doing things, but it is wisdom in God’s economy. We should never diminish the scandal of the cross.”

—”The Suffering Servant,” Ligonier Ministries,  4/19/2013

We are told to let our light shine and if it does, we don’t need to tell anybody it does. Lighthouses don’t fire cannons to call attention to their shining – they just shine.

—D. L. Moody

Key Illustrations

Heroic Sacrifice

You may remember that in January of 1982, Air Florida Flight 90 crashed into the icy Potomac River right after takeoff. While 74 passengers and crew perished, several were saved by the actions of a heroic passenger, later identified as Arland Williams. Williams stayed in the river, helping others get to shore or to other rescuers. He then disappeared and is presumed to have died. He gave his life so that others might live. His sacrifice is a model of Jesus’ words in John 15:13 that greater love is in laying down one’s life for friends. A decision to suffer with Jesus is described by Terence Fretheim:

This is the shape of life needed to rid the world of suffering. Jesus stands in a long tradition of righteous ones, whose mission on behalf of life is carried forward in and through suffering. His followers are called to give a suffering shape to their daily lives for the sake of the life of others (I Peter 2:21).

—Eunice McGarrahan

Sarah Smith of Golders Green

One of the most powerful expressions of humble, servant-like caring for others is found in C.S. Lewis’ The Great Divorce, in the character of Sarah Smith of Golders Green. Her quiet life of love transformed the lives of everyone she encountered, even down to the little animals in her care. Of her life’s impact, a character says, “It is like when you throw a stone into a pool, and the concentric waves spread out further and further. Who knows where it will end? …But already there is joy enough in the little finger of a great saint such as yonder lady to waken all the dead things of the universe into life.”

Eunice McGarrahan

 

Discussion Questions

  • What do we think of when we think of those who are “perishing?”
  • Are there ways that we might find comfort in being veiled from truth?
  • How does the world try to veil our understanding of Jesus as Lord?
  • Do you know someone—even yourself—who has gone from dark to light?
  • Do we make it clear that Jesus is Lord and we are servants?  If we keep that distinction in mind, would it make our witness easier?  Harder?

Liturgical resources

Call to Worship

Adapted from John 3:16-17

Leader: For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life.

People: For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn us, but in order that we might be saved through him.

Leader: On this day of greatest sorrow and greatest hope, let us worship the Lord, our savior.

People: We will worship the Lord in spirit and truth!

(John 3:16-17, some wording modified for liturgical use, ESV)

Opening Prayer

Lord, we come to the foot of your cross to wonder at the love you have shown us. You said, “Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends,” and then you stretched out your arms on the hard wood of the cross and demonstrated what you meant. Give us now the love that we, too, pick up the cross and carry it forward to be witnesses of your love to this world.

—William Rowley (John 15:13, ESV)

Prayer of Confession

Most Holy God, it is a dreadful moment when we realize that we have offended you.
We have rejected your leading and like sheep, we have wandered far from you.
Our wandering has taken us to dark places, and we cannot find our way home.
But you, O God, are already in our dark place, suffering with us in our distress. By
your Holy Spirit enable us to follow you faithfully as you lead us home. Amen

—Eunice McGarrahan

Assurance of Pardon

Adapted from 2 Corinthians 5:21

The Apostle Paul reminds us in his second letter to the Corinthians that for our sake, God made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God. So, believe the good news of the gospel, in Jesus Christ our sins are forgiven. Alleluia. Amen.

—Eunice McGarrahan

Benediction

Surely he has borne our griefs
and carried our sorrows…
He was pierced for our transgressions;
he was crushed for our iniquities;
upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace,
and with his wounds we are healed.

Go forth in the knowledge that our Lord loves you so much that he conquered death for you. Live the eternal life he promised as you go out into the world, redeemed and transformed.

Isaiah 53:4a & 5 (ESV)

Detail of a Doré painting of Jesus Christ descending the steps of a building surrounded on all sides by a hostile crowd. He is preceded by a Roman soldier. A man holds a cross at the bottom of the steps. Mary watches on from the right.
Detail of Christ Leaves the Court by Gustav Doré, btw. 1867 and 1872. Oil on canvas.
Strasbourg Museum of Modern and Contemporary Art.
Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

More Quotes: Good Friday

More Illustrations: Good Friday

Eunice McGarrahan

Eunice McGarrahan

Eunice (“Junior”) McGarrahan is Teaching Pastor at the First Presbyterian Church in Colorado Springs. She has served as an Associate for Theology in the Office of Theology and Worship (PCUSA), as associate pastor at The National Presbyterian Church in Washington, DC, as well as other churches in Virginia and Kentucky. After thirty years of youth ministry, Junior went to Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary where she received her M. Div. And Th.M. She received her Doctor of Ministry degree from University of Dubuque Theological Seminary, writing on the Eucharistic theology of the Heidelberg Catechism. She is married and the McGarrahans have one son who lives and works in the DC area.